I've been hearing a lot about Class Dojo lately, so I decided to look into it and created an account for myself. For those of you who aren't familiar...
You can log in on a computer and see your class
(Note: this is a sample class. I do not teach Matt Damon and Johnny Depp)
Or, you can use the Class Dojo app on your iPad or iPhone
From the data perspective, I think this looks like a great way to collect data on student behavior and have sufficient info readily available for report cards and conferences.
However, I am not sure I really understand how this motivates kids and how functional it is to keep track of an entire class using this system. I thought I heard that the app makes different noises depending on whether you make a note of positive or negative behavior, but that's not happening when I use it on my phone. Maybe I need to change a setting or something...
Anyway, I have also run into
this article on facebook a few times this week. It has got me thinking about the behavior management system I use and, honestly, has got me feeling a bit defensive due to all the educators out there arguing that a visible behavior management system (like the red, yellow, green stoplight one pictured in the article) is "publicly shaming" children. I do not at all feel that the system I use shames children or embarrasses them in front of their peers; yet, that article just makes me think because I would
never want that to be the case and
many educators are against such systems.
Things that make you go hmmm....
So I looked into class Dojo as an alternative. If I managed this data on my iPad, it wouldn't be "out there" for all students to see. Yet, am I not supposed to let a student know when they are not behaving according to my expectations? Is that supposed to be a secret? If I make a verbal comment about who is getting a point or losing a point, then the kids are still aware of who is "good" and who is "not good." If I don't say anything and just plug it in, how exactly are kids getting specific feedback?
Can someone walk me through this please????
Do you Dojo?
What makes Class Dojo different from those others systems?
Do you find it easy to manage?
The system I currently use involves each child having three sticks that they keep/lose based on their behavior. At the beginning of the year sticks are replaced daily, then as they become competent with rules/procedures, the sticks are only replaced weekly (Once a stick is lost, it is out for the remainder of the week). Sticks are lost when students are not following expectations. Each students' sticks are in a little pocket so they can see how many they have. If all three sticks are lost, a student does not earn choice time on Friday. Instead of choice time, they sit with me and talk about why they lost sticks and I fill out a note to send home to parents that needs to be signed and returned. Students who have 1, 2, or 3 sticks on Friday get to have choice time (which lasts 15 minutes). Students who keep all 3 sticks for the whole week get a special certificate to acknowledge their good behavior on Friday and we clap for them.
Personally, I don't see anything horrible about this system. Yet, comments from other teachers on the stoplight system post made me feel uncomfortable. When teachers throw out words like "punitive behavior management" and "publicly shaming" to describe something that I am doing, I do not feel good about it. I don't agree; yet, these are knowledgable professionals who are finding huge fault with something that I am using. It's not personal, but it is. Is calling a child out for poor behavior truly "shaming" them? I don't want children to feel stress or embarrassment, but I do want them to know what is okay and what is not okay.
Some things I am considering for this year:
- using numbers instead of names on the chart I have posted (easy)
- moving the chart closer to my desk so it is more private (easy)
- replacing lost sticks during the week for good behavior (not sure how this would play out)
- using a new system altogether (maybe Dojo)
Please tell me your thoughts!
I want my behavior management system to focus on the positive and I think I do that because kids are excited to keep their sticks and most kids keep their sticks most week. If a stick is lost, it comes with a reminder that whatever behavior that caused it is not okay. I'm not mean, I don't yell, and I certainly don't shame kids when they lose a stick. When three sticks are lost they don't play, but is this a consequence or punishment? What's the difference? Most of the time every child earns choice time. Most of the time, kids who lose a stick realize they don't like to lose sticks and make efforts to keep them by following expectations. When kids struggle with the system, I don't let them continuously fail, I provide them with something more tailored to their needs.
Lots of questions in today's post because I really want your feedback and input!